FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OVER $100!* | SHOP NEW ARRIVALS
Our Story
If you've never shopped with us before, you're in for a treat! Join the Happy Selection of resale jewelry you can find — at prices lower than what it costs to make them.
35+
Years of Excellence
11
Team Members
A+
BBB Rating
4.7★
Customer Rating
Unbeatable Prices
We guarantee the lowest prices on certified diamonds and fine jewelry.
GIA Standards
All our diamonds are certified by GIA ensuring the highest quality.
On-Site Jewelers
Expert craftsmen available for custom designs and repairs.
Same Warranty
Industry-leading warranty on all our products and services.
Buy With Confidence
We're proud to hold an A+ rating with both the Better Business Bureau and the Jewelers Board of Trade. We also hold a 4.7-star Google rating with over 600 reviews from satisfied customers. Since 1988, we've grown to 11 stores across Kentucky and Ohio, each fully staffed with a team of dedicated and knowledgeable professionals providing the highest quality jewelry at the lowest prices.
“Every once in a while someone tells me they've found a piece of jewelry for less at another store. The first thing I ask is, ‘Which one of our other stores were you shopping in?’ We encourage you to look around — armed with the knowledge we give you. When you compare quality, you won't find a better deal anywhere on the planet.”
– Matt Blethen, E-Commerce Director
We Educate Our Customers
At The Castle, our sales associates attend training classes every other week. Our team adheres to GIA (Gemological Institute of America)standards on diamond grading, with GIA certified professionals on staff. We love to share that knowledge with you. We'll teach you how to use a loupe, train you to spot inclusions — or the lack thereof — in diamonds you're interested in, and show you how to apply that knowledge to clarity and color charts so you know exactly what you're buying.
How We Offer The Lowest Prices
We Pay Fair for Inventory
We pay fair prices for quality jewelry pieces. This means our inventory costs significantly less than retail prices, allowing us to pass the savings to you.
From Estate Sales to You
Being a direct shop means no middlemen. We source from estate sales and pass those savings directly to you at the lowest prices.
Lower Markup, Better Deals
Unlike competitors, our markup is significantly lower. We focus on volume and customer satisfaction rather than high margins.
Lifetime Price Guarantee
Find a lower price elsewhere? We'll match it. Our pricing has already been marked down, but we stand behind our commitment to value.
Common Questions
Ready to Experience The Castle Difference?
Whether you're shopping for an engagement ring or looking for a special piece of fine jewelry.
Start Shopping